Fri, 05 Jun 2020

Why philosophy is an ideal travel companion for adventurous minds

The Conversation
28 Feb 2020, 04:16 GMT+10

In 2019, there were 1.4 billion international tourist arrivals globally - and, given that the planet only holds 7.7 billion humans, this figure alone suggests that a lot of us are travelling. The World Tourism Organization reports two major motivations for this - "travel to change": the quest for local experiences, authenticity, transformation and "travel to show": the desire for Instagramable moments and destinations.

I think both trends are fuelled by curiosity about the unknown, the unfamiliar. Humans have always looked for new experiences, ways to live, things to show to others. Travel magazines are strewn with articles about visiting "overlooked" and "unknown" places - and this curiosity has a long history.

Throughout his Antarctic explorations, Apsley Cherry-Garrard yearns for "unknown" places. Mary Kingsley describes the "sheer good pleasure" of canoeing down an "unknown" West African river by moonlight, and delights in places "not down" on maps. A character in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness describes how "inviting" the "blank spaces on the earth" seem and tells us about his hankering for "the biggest, the most blank".

Philosophy can also be about exploring the unknown. In one of his groundbreaking books on idealism, 18th-century Irish philosopher George Berkeley likened his investigations to a "long Voyage", involving difficult travel across "wild Mazes of Philosophy". Scottish Enlightenment philosopher David Hume offers similar reflections halfway through his most radical sceptical work A Treatise of Human Nature.

He imagines himself as a sailor who has struck shallow water, narrowly escaping shipwreck. Safety tempts him to remain perched on the rocks, rather than venturing out onto "that boundless ocean, which runs out into immensity". Yet Hume decides he will put out to sea again, in the same "leaky weather-beaten vessel".

Wild mazes of thought

The "philosophy of travel" isn't a thing. It isn't the subject of lecture courses, or conferences - there are no lists of great philosophical travellers. But, as I argue in my new book The Meaning of Travel: Philosophers Abroad, travel and philosophy have enjoyed a quiet love affair for centuries.

Travellers and philosophers can both aim at pushing the limits of their knowledge - at seeing how the world is. Adventurous travellers covet new places - even Earth's unexplored oceans and planets around distant stars. Radical philosophers crafts new questions and shake old assumptions. What is time? Or matter? Or goodness?

You might think wishing for the unknown is the only thing philosophy and travel have in common. Travel involves trains, passports, luggage. Philosophy involves books, ethics, bearded Greeks. But despite their differences, travel and philosophy are tangled together. Travel has affected philosophy, and philosophy has affected travel.

Travel can help philosophers develop new questions. For example, 17th-century European travellers began bringing home, en masse, reports of foreign customs and beliefs. John Locke, the "father of liberalism" - and a voracious reader of travel books - discussed practices that Europeans found shocking. His Essay Concerning Human Understanding describes cannibalism among peoples in Georgia, the Caribbean and Peru; the immodest sex lives of Turkish saints; and atheism running rampant throughout China and Thailand.

Some of these reports were erroneous: reports of cannibalism were exaggerated, while - even then - China and Thailand had long religious traditions. But it was becoming clear that people across the planet disagree about ethics and religion. Locke used these disagreements to raise a philosophical question. Are there any innate ideas that all humans are born knowing? (For Locke, the answer was "no".)

New questions

Travel is still prompting new questions today. What are the ethics of doom tourism, to places affected by climate change? Can we imagine what other, non-human minds are like? How might space travel affect us?

Just as travel has moved philosophy forward, philosophy has sometimes pushed travel practices in new directions. Every so often, a new philosophical idea impels travel to particular places, or in particular ways. For example, American literary scholar Marjorie Hope Nicolson's Mountain Gloom, Mountain Glory argues that, from the late 17th century, a new theory of space incited tourists to visit mountains. On this "Absolute" theory, space is God's immensity or infinite presence.

Nicolson argues this led to people perceiving big, infinite landscapes such as mountains as divine. "Great cathedrals of the earth" - as the Victorian thinker John Ruskin wrote of the Alps - "altars of snow". Once mountains had become cathedrals, everybody wanted to visit them.

Similarly, the philosophy of wilderness set out in American philosopher Henry Thoreau's Walden started a craze for solitary wilderness travel - and cabin porn.

What counts as unknown depends on your starting point. For British sailor James Cook, Alaska and Australia were "new" lands - but their indigenous inhabitants knew them well. Roman Syria would have been unfamiliar to Chinese explorer Gan Ying, but not to the Syrians. Sometimes journeys explore places unknown to all human beings: the depths of Son Doong caves, the under-snow mountains of Antarctica, the Moon and Mars.

Philosophers can also venture into areas of thought that are new to them but familiar to others. I would have this experience if I began researching medieval German philosophy, or contemporary Chinese philosophy. And philosophers can attempt to strike out into wholly new areas of thought. I think this is when philosophy and travel are at their most fascinating: when they look to the borders of what humans do not know.

Author: Emily Thomas - Associate Professor of Philosophy, Durham University The Conversation

More United Kingdom News

Access More

Sign up for United Kingdom News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!